Monday, June 27, 2022

Language Insanity Sweeping Quebec

Back in high school, a million years ago, I learnt a valuable lesson about the human condition, not in the classroom, but in the most unlikely of places.

Over fifty years ago, the scene in Montreal's Northmount High cafeteria of an out-of-control food fight remains indelibly stamped in my mind.
It started out innocently enough but before you knew it, too many otherwise rational and level-headed students were flinging food across the room in an orgy-like scene of mayhem and depravity.
The lunchroom monitors' efforts to intervene and restore a semblance of order proved woefully ineffective and it was abundantly clear that there was no stopping the bedlam as adrenaline coursed through the bodies of the frenzied participants, a scene that would ultimately play out to its exhausted conclusion.
While the majority of students in the cafeteria participated in the pandemonium, a significant minority either fled the scene or sat in utter dumbfounded amazement, taking in the scene in abject disbelief (myself included) wondering what mystical evil force had overtaken these people?

The lesson I took from that scene was that ordinary people can get caught up in the moment and despite their better and rational judgment be swept up by the mob into acting irrationally or otherwise believing commonly held nonsense just because everyone seems to be doing it or believing it.

When the Stanley cup riots occurred in Montreal it explained why normally law-abiding citizens deemed it acceptable to break windows along Ste. Catherine street and loot the stores.
And you'll no doubt remember that aspiring young lawyer who mugged before the camera wearing a thong over her mouth instead of a mask, mocking and insulting sanitary measures as the party aboard a chartered Sunwing jet turned into a drunken debacle. The personal and professional consequences were devastating.
 What on Earth was she thinking?

Collective insanity is even more dangerous when it applies to entire populations as demonstrated by Hitler's successful campaign to convince rational and usually level-headed German people that their misfortunes were all the fault of the Jews.
How could almost the entire nation embrace a patently false, libellous and dangerous concept so gratuitously?

And recently Valdimar Putin demonstrated that even in a modern world, the majority can embrace utter and complete nonsense in believing his concocted nonsense that Ukrainian Nazis posed a threat to Mother Russia, to the point that close to 100,000 Russian casualties have so far been sacrificed over a fantasy with nary a complaint.
And the saddest part is that once in the throws of hysteria there is no reasoning, no convincing, no abating and certainly no useful debate to be had.

Sadly such is the case here in Quebec, where mass hysteria over language has taken root, spurred on by a cynical and evil Premier Legault who channels Putin in callously fomenting rage and disgust over fantasy, the nonsense wherein Quebec is deemed to be under existential threat over language.

Just like a food fight which starts off mildly enough, with one idiot tossing a single plate of food, it inevitably escalates into an orgy of depravity, placing Quebec on the very same path of idiotic and hurtful excess.

Like Hitler's taunts over the dangerous Jews and Putin's taunts over Ukrainian Nazis, Legault's xenophobic and anglophilic missives have gained wide acceptance in the media, the true driver of public opinion.

In Russia, Putin's media sycophants are doing his dirty work, inflaming public opinion with hateful and racist rhetoric, and providing much-needed backing for the tragic Ukrainian war.


It's easy to understand that facts don't matter to these people and debate is a useless exercise in futility. Truth doesn't matter when a popular lie is so convenient and fun.
Like Donald Trump's loyal followers who still believe that the presidential election was stolen, no amount of debate, facts or truth will sway their unshaken faith in the lie.
There's no use in trying to convince them otherwise

Sadly the same is occurring in Quebec with our evil Premier and his racist minister Simon Jolin-Barrette spewing the vilest of untruths about English, anglophone and ethnics aided and abetted by a compliant media of closeted and open separatists eager to push the falsehood in order to promote their dogged pursuance of the twice rejected sovereignty option.
It is in fact the perfect storm of cognitive dissonance.

The Premier is being emboldened by the wide acceptance and media backing of his nonsense, upping the rhetoric with each week, recently offering up  this hateful missive
"It's important that we don't put all cultures on the same level; that's why we oppose multiculturalism," Legault said.
All this to say, that here in Quebec we are well past the nascent stage of collective insanity. 
There can be no debate or discourse with those dedicated to the lie of French fragility.

And the more we complain, the stronger the movement. grows.
No committee, political party, scholarly articles in the Press or any countervailing action or movement can have the slightest effect.
In fact, opposition and dissent to the idea of an existential threat to French in Quebec feeds into the paranoia, further strengthening the idea that Quebec stands alone against the world.

Parroting Putin's and Hitler's paranoiac exhortations that their societies are in mortal danger because of evil outside forces, posing an existential threat, Legault and his evil minions have employed the historically tried and true device of scapegoating and blame to cast anglos and ethnics as the enemies of the state.

Sadly, there is nothing we can do to stop the insanity.
Like those students uninvolved in the food fight, all we can do is observe the depravity and hope it ends soon.

I'm not so sure it will.

16 comments:

  1. Should've wished the OUI won in '95
    Would've partitioned out of Quebec
    and into Ontario

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hmmm...it seems ambiguity is the order of the day. Mikef, what do you mean "partitioned out of Quebec and into Ontario"? Do you mean Quebec itself would be partitioned with the partitioned part integrating with Ontario, or do you mean you'd move out of Quebec to Ontario? Please clarify.

      Delete
    2. Where do you get the idea that a Separatist plurality in their 1995 referendum meant a legal "partitioning" of anything in Canada either Constitutionally or under International Law?

      Delete
    3. P.S. - the above was posted by anonymous 99

      Delete
  2. I am probably the largest and most loyal contributor to this blog. This whole article is very vague. While the rhetoric is contributing to more tensions in Quebec, what exactly are you getting at, Phil?

    Is there more intimidation and violence by the general population towards minorities? I can somewhat see that against those wearing religious clothing and symbols that are conspicuously not those of the "commonfolk" (take that term anyway you want), but that's not clear here; too, it would be nothing new. Are there fistfights suddenly happening in the streets? Sorry, Phil, but this article covers to broad and ambiguous an area to comment on sensibly.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Some afterthoughts: Considering how few people are contributing to this blog, especially with Bills 21 and 96, the two most egregious laws passed since the late 80s, and the fact there is absolutely no civil disobedience taking place, I must conclude that legislation of this sort is being met with indifference.

    For years and decades, you had the like of that Wilson fellow (news director?) on CTV's Channel 12 news yapping about the horribleness of the attacks on minorities and the English language, same during that post-noon "free-for-all" on CJAD with the late Gord Sinclair et al, and even back in the days when Howard Galganov had his own radio phone-in show in the 1990s AND his blog. Galganov dropped the Quebec situation with reckless abandon from his blog and changed his focus to ultra right-wing crap in the U.S.

    In previous hearings that took place a few years ago in the National Assembly where the likes of one Irwin Rappaport and supposed activist Hugo Shebbeare made statements, nothing has been done by the minorities to fight, so I'm left to the conclusion that there is no fight left in the dog, or again, there is indifference. Whining and complaining just isn't going to cut it. I guess leaving Quebec in the mid-80s was the smartest choice. For a long time, I encouraged peers to leave. Some did. Others stayed.

    I like to think I've matured over the years. I thought anyone who chose to stay and complain needed to have their head examined. I now accept that there are those who like Montreal and area, and that's that. I guess I am forced to accept that the Quebec government and its majority can attack the minorities anyway they want with neither resistance nor impunity. It looks as if you in the minority demographic are on your own, and good luck with that!

    It's too bad, really, because prospects for Anglophones, even those who have learned to speak and/or write French with solid proficiency, if not fluency, are, and have fallen behind economically for ages. Indicators show it will only get worse with no evidence of improvement. You want to be sitting ducks? Bonne chance with that!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ukraine is indeed a little like Quebec, in terms of language laws that attack a language that is perceived to be too strong and unwanted (Russian language in Ukraine's case, English language in Quebec's case). Canada *would* be like Russia if it had the cojones to do what Russia did - roll into Quebec and carve out from it the territories that don't appreciate bill 101 too much.

    https://www.reuters.com/article/us-ukraine-parliament-language-idUSKCN1S111N

    And comparing people to the Nazis is an obsession of this blogger, stemming from an ailment common to his ethnicity, what Gilad Atzmon has aptly dubbed a *pre*-traumatic stress disorder.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really appreciate Mr Berlachs' creation and maintenance of this blog. I also believe at this blogs creator and owner has 100% editorial authority to post whatever topic he wants to.

    However I think posting about unrelated topics is hurting participation, especially so during this crucial time of bill 101 version 2.0.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. J.P.: I agree with you 100%, but editorials are inert. A far more assertive protest is not. Organize a serious protest. Hold up the J.C. Bridge the way Kahnawake did the Mercier Bridge. The J.C. bridge is the most used and it is less used by the minorities. Same with the L-H Bridge/Tunnel. Organize a blockade and get media attention...maybe from the U.S. as well.

      Delete
  6. Actually, adski, a language revolt was also had in Latvia and I wouldn't be surprised if other Baltic states did as well. Shortly after the Baltic states became independent, Latvia outlawed the posting of Russian signs, etc. I just never heard whether or not other Baltic states followed suit.

    Additionally, but sadly, once Russia sufficiently overtakes Ukraine, like death, taxes, green grass and blue skies, Putin will go after other former republics as well unless Western nations pool together and fight. Then again, there will be enemies, big ones, like China, the Little Rocket Man in North Korea and other rogue states.

    Sadly, the likelihood of "carving out" and partitioning Quebec for the minorities will never be implemented by the major federal parties. They all rely too much on Quebec voters (why the Conservatives do, though, is beyond reason), unless MAYBE Jean Charest wins. He'll do the opposite. He'll end up with a brown nose up Quebec's collective _ _ _!

    ReplyDelete
  7. 1) No, what Mr. Berlach demonstrated was the use of propaganda by the Nazis with that of Premier Legault to achieve their goal.
    2) "Canada who is like Russia, trying to impose its will on a smaller neighbor." A Neighbor? Quebec is one of ten provinces of Canada. Methinks it's impossible for the country to pick on itself.
    signed.... anonymous 99

    ReplyDelete
  8. P.S. the above was posted by anonymous 99

    ReplyDelete
  9. "the use of propaganda by the Nazis with that of Premier Legault to achieve their goal" - the Nazis learned propaganda from the Americans. So to be more precise, Premier Legault uses propaganda invented and practiced by the American J*w Bernays to achieve his goals.

    https://theconversation.com/the-manipulation-of-the-american-mind-edward-bernays-and-the-birth-of-public-relations-44393

    "In the 1920s, Joseph Goebbels became an avid admirer of Bernays and his writings – despite the fact that Bernays was a Jew. When Goebbels became the minister of propaganda for the Third Reich, he sought to exploit Bernays’ ideas to the fullest extent possible. For example, he created a “Fuhrer cult” around Adolph Hitler."

    ReplyDelete
  10. https://bb-cntv.com/news/in-ukraine-zelensky-was-accused-of-violating-the-language-law-94094/

    "Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky violated the law on the use of the language during public events, said the language ombudsman Taras Kremin, the Strana edition reports. He noted that the president spoke English during meetings with British businessman Richard Branson on June 29, as well as with actor and director Sean Penn on June 28. According to Ukrainian legislation, during cultural public events it is necessary to speak the state language. In addition to Zelensky, Kremin revealed violations of another 25 officials."

    ReplyDelete
  11. As Ukrainization of the West proceeds unimpeded, the process of Quebecisation of Ukraine seems to also be underway:

    "On 16 July 2022, a new set of provisions of the Law of Ukraine "On Ensuring the Functioning of the Ukrainian Language as the State Language" ("Law") will come into force, including requirements concerning the language of software user interfaces and websites."

    https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=2635fc6e-7bf4-417c-b384-c97b374a2b9c

    Ukrainization of the West is really becoming something btw - my small southern Quebec town's city hall has even hoisted a Ukrainian flag and *removed* the Quebec flag, so the Ukrainian flag is currently the *only* flag flying at the city hall, while the town's RBC branch hits you with Ukrainian flags on electronic info-boards as soon as you enter the bank. The electronic advertisement billboard down the town's main road also flips between commercial ads and ... drumroll please .. an image of a Ukrainian flag. There's no escape from this insanity.

    ReplyDelete
  12. "100,000 Russian casualties have so far been sacrificed"

    Lol. Many of these "100K" must have been killed by the "ghost of Kiev".

    Keep it coming NoDogs.

    ReplyDelete