In 2002 the PQ government wanted to eliminate these towns because many had anglophone majorities which qualified them for bilingual status, something the separatists abhorred. The PQ government hatched a plan to eliminate these towns by forcing them to merge with Montreal, thus bringing the anglophone component down below the threshold required for bilingual status.
When the Liberal government of Jean Charest came to power it did so on an election plank which would allow the former towns the right to de-merge through referenda held in each former town if they so desired.
The towns didn't get off scot-free, they were forced to continue to live with the elimination of their police and fire services and instead, over-pay Montreal for inferior service. The towns were also required to continue to contribute taxes to Montreal as a forced tribute.
But the towns of Westmount, Mount-Royal, Hampstead and Cote Saint-Luc are smack dab in the middle of the island, occupying prime real-estate. Westmount sitting on the top of the mountain with its multi-million dollar homes and the Town of Mount-Royal with its famous separation wall along L'Acadie Boulevard remain symbols of the hated English domination of the city.
While nobody in the French media will say it out loud, these bastions of English privilege remain galling, vestiges of a colonial past that just won't disappear.
And so the announcement by the Town of Mount-Royal that it will be building a massive shopping, entertainment and dining complex on its territory was bound to elicit howls of protest from anti-anglophone forces appalled that such a mega project on the island could fall outside its control and worse, shift the focus of tourists and shoppers away from downtown.
This week the City of Montreal's planning department complained with great fanfare that the project would add 30 minutes to the commute of some travelling along the derelict Metropolitan Boulevard, a monument to Quebec transportation and construction incompetence.
The traffic study offered by the city is so flawed that it begs the questions as to whether it was serious in the first place, or a propaganda tool meant to throw cold water on the project.
The city claims that up to 70,000 cars will travel to and from the mall each day, this with announced parking facilities of just 8,000 places.
Where will these supposed cars park?
The study forecasted up to 140,000 will visit the mall each day, half arriving by bus and metro, the other half by car. This number is wildly optimistic considering that the West Edmonton Mall which is about two and a half times bigger receives between 90,000 and 200,000 visitors per day.
The study does not consider that most mall traffic occurs on the weekend when fewer commuters are travelling to work.
A reasonable assumption is that the mall when completed will attract about 40,000 visitors during the week and about double on the weekend.
Of the 40,000 daily visitors during the week, half will arrive by public transport and the other half by car (according to the study itself) thus leaving 20,000 visitors arriving by car. Calculating one and a half persons per car, it means 13,500 additional car visits per weekday a figure half of what the study indicated.
The study also fails to consider that the mall only opens after the morning rush hour. The hours between 4 o'clock and 7 o'clock (the evening rush hour) are the quietest shopping hours of the day, as any retailer can attest. Evening shopping starts picking up after 7 o'clock.
The rush-hour bogeyman put forth by the study is a crock.
It's not surprising the mall owners disputed the figures vehemently, but it is strange that no media outlet bothered challenging the city's math.
At any rate, the TMR project known as Royalmount is a complete and utter threat to Montreal's perceived image as a French only city. The mega centre is located in an officially bilingual town, meaning all signage can be posted bilingually. Bonjour/ Hi will reign supreme and since the mall will become a tourist attraction, it will serve as a not-so-gentle reminder to tourists that Montreal is indeed a bilingual city.
Not a situation that nationalists can abide by.
And so the attacks on the project begin, with all sorts of reasons being put forward to thwart the projected mall.
Luc Ferandez who reigns as mayor over the hipster Plateau-Mont-Royal borough is raging against the project claiming that it will turn Montreal into a shopping mecca like Dubai, an unacceptable situation.
While complaints about the project are couched in false arguments, leave it to the readers of the Journal de Montreal to complain in the comments section about the English nature of the project.
"Oufff...qu'il commence donc par lui donner un nom Français ! Loi 101 où es- tu ?"Yes, the hidden contempt and jealousy for any Anglo success is palpable.
"How about starting by giving the project French name. Where is Bill 101?"
Royalmount? Pourquoi un nom en anglais? Montréal est en train de redevenir cette metropole anglaise du début du 20ieme siècle..
"Royalmount? Why an English name? Montreal is returning to the English city of the early 20th century"
Bien oui, merci à Jean Charest et ses défusions: c'est ça avoir de la vision pour le Québec et sa métropole.
"Yes sir, thanks to Jean Charest and his de-mergers: that is the vision for Quebec and its metropolis."
In a snarky opinion piece in HuffpostQuebec that dripped with venom, a contributor rained down contempt for the project as well as the English communities of Hampstead and Cote Saint-Luc.
Pascal Henrard described leaving the lovely and peaceful environs of his native Plateau Mont-Royal on a bicycle trip to visit the new location of the Royalmount project. He described his bike ride as a Montreal dream until he arrived at the hateful town limits of Hampstead where shiny SUV eyesores littered streets that seemed to lead nowhere and where rude drivers and residents who never seemed to have seen a cyclist before, honked at him incessantly.
Attempting to cross over to the Royalmount property in TMR via Cavendish (I assume from his description of the four-lane street)) he was dismayed to find the way blocked by railway tracks that conveniently, according to him, separated the rich from the poor, notwithstanding that nobody, rich or poor, really lives on the other side of the tracks.
The only thing he missed and failed to assail was the one-word 'STOP' signs in Hampstead that Bill 101ers abhor. I can only assume he missed this insulting travesty because, well, cyclists are blind to stop signs.
So expect anglophobic opposition to the project to ramp up, with all sorts of excuses offered as to why the project should be stymied.
Expect pressure to be exerted on the Provincial government which is the only government that can effectively slow or stymie the project. Towns and cities are 100% under its purview, but given the advanced stage of the project, with hundreds of millions committed and with demolition already underway, there is little to be done without incurring a huge legal liability.
So to my fulminating anglophobe foils all I can say is that you seemed to be checkmated by events or perhaps in language you can better understand, the Royalmount project just may be a fait accompli.
1 of 2: Thanks for the amusing read, Phil! I didn't know thing one about this project, but thanks for keeping me abreast of the 19th Century happenings in good ol' Montreal.
ReplyDeleteOne correction though. I don't believe it's the Francophones who were responsible for the L'Acadie Blvd. fence. I can be wrong, but my family and I perceived it as a means for the TMR people to look down their noses at the less affluent heavily immigrant families of Park Ex, a.k.a, the riffraff.
Be that as it may, is Royalmount (Royalmont?) really a French name? Of course, I'm inclined to say 'who cares', but of course that would be redundant of where I speak!
The City of Montreal has always provided services that are at the bottom of the heap. A buddy of mine started a charity softball team that played primarily at Hampstead Park, a very well-kept facility with courteous city staff that gave them a discount and some freebies because they were serving the community. He'd have to start with a Montreal-run park in NDG in May as the Hampstead facility was prioritized to locally run baseball games then, and he said the Montreal people were rude dogs. They'd demand a cheque before even speaking to him, they wouldn't paint foul lines, provide bases and the drinking fountains and bathroom facilities were always locked (and likely in a horrid state of disrepair). The garbage trucks running down NDG streets would just impudently block the streets while collecting trash totally ignoring the traffic lining up behind. What anal pigs!
To compare Montreal to Mississauga (yes, I'm bragging to the hilt to show you and your readers why Ontario, while not perfection, is many, many levels closer to it. Least important, but a nice benefit, is we have a sexy mayor (aged 58) named Bonnie Crombie (no relation to the former Toronto mayor, David, of several decades ago). Yes, before that we had an ugly bulldog at the helm, but she had the tenacity and character of a bulldog, named Hazel McCallion (who BTW was born in Port Daniel, in Gaspésie). She served as our mayor for 36 years (i.e., before I moved to Mississauga) and retired from the job in 2014 at the age of 93. Next Valentine's Day she WILL be turning 98, and she has forgotten more about being a mayor than Drapeau every knew and would know if he lived to 198!
Next, our roads are paved and upgraded long before any and all Quebec roads are barely looked at. My street, not in too bad condition to begin with, was repaved within the last ten years. When I last saw my old street in Chomedey (about six months ago), same ol' asphalt from circa 1962 with the subsequent patchwork (circa 1967) still there plus broken pavement. When's the last time your street was paved?
2 of 2: Also, about a dozen years ago, a small bridge crossing over a ravine around the corner from my home was redone. It wasn't in anywhere near decrepit shape, just looked a little tired. No masking paint job, no fixing any cracks, just totally torn down and redone.
DeleteOh yeah, and we still have the Square One Shopping Centre second in size only to the West Edmonton Mall. In all fairness to you dear readers, I'll throw you a bone. Carrefour Laval did a very nice job on one wing with upgraded stores only the minorities and well overpaid Quebec government workers can afford with a nicely created mosaic along the corridor.
I also live near Lake Ontario and we have some gorgeous parks along the lakeshore. The washrooms are open, the water fountains work, and they even have barbecues in place (BYOC - bring your own charcoal). Has Montreal even ever thought of installing barbecues? [Place tear-jerking, belly-aching laugh here!]
BTW, how's the infrastructure re-do going with the Champlain Bridge, Ville Marie, Highway 20 et al going? How long will these structures last? 20 years, maybe, sort of like that 2nd overpass in Chomedey that collapsed in 2000 while the old overpass kept right on trucking? Can I expect the new Champlain Bridge to still be properly standing with the Victoria Bridge (almost 160 years old)? I somehow see that old lady as holding up longer. Naturally! It was neither designed nor constructed by Francophones!
Even that second Cartierville Bridge (circa 1975) looks like it's crumbling next to the old bridge built in the 40s or 50s! ...or maybe earlier. Betcha buncha blintzes these new structures won't even last as long as the current ones mostly built to host Expo 67.
Anyway, enough bragging. My point here is to show that this is just another chapter in the endless escapades of jealousy and incompetence of the majority focused on the minorities who have infinitely more smarts, more ingenuity and more money than "them". Eat your jealous little hearts out, student, and the rest of you!
Anglo Bastions 1, Montreal 0. Outskirts outside the Greater Montreal Area, you need about 20 years of concerted efforts to maybe get to zero! Failure state!
"While nobody in the French media will say it out loud, these bastions of English privilege remain galling, vestiges of a colonial past that just won't disappear."
ReplyDeleteThe existence of the French language in North America is itself a vestige of colonialism (by France, obviously). By some magical process, no one seems to ever seems to remember this whenever they decide to dump on colonialism.
I wasn’t a fan of the Royalmount project... until I found out that some dingleberries simply object to the name, so now I’m converted... not! But I don’t mind seeing them get pissed off. Referring to the first quote in the post, I couldn’t help noticing how the anglophobe Sylvie Renaud thinks Bill 101 is a magic wand that makes English go away in Quebec. Meanwhile, she posts her vacation photos from Florida and Texas while disrespecting the right of anglo-Quebecers to exist and thrive... a typical separatist hypocrite. I don’t know why she lives in Montreal. She should move to Rimouski or Chicoutimi if she wants to live in French-only “purity”.
ReplyDeleteOK, I had my fun, now down to business. I think Montreal is lucky to get a facility like this, considering the Recréathèque no longer exists. A water park in Montreal? I for sure wouldn't invest in one because summers in Montreal are too short. I don't see them being open long enough, unless it's supposed to be an indoor facility much like the Great Wolf Lodge chain in Niagara Falls, Ohio and Washington State. Actually they have all had bedbug problems!
ReplyDeleteOne would think Montrealers would be thrilled to finally have a facility that is successful in the rest of North America. Seems Quebec always has a bee in their bonnet. No more major league baseball team, no chance in hell of the NFL coming to Montreal (yes, I know, Toronto is having a hard time of it, but at least some NFL games came to Toronto). All there is is hockey and thankfully enough ethnic minorities to float a soccer team. Even the Als are just in a university stadium so that Big Owe is just a deteriorating white elephant.
C'mon you morons (mostly the Francophones), do you want to be a world-class city, or continue to deteriorate into the also-rans you've become with the language B.S. started 45 years ago.
Phil wrote about the super hockey arena a number of years ago built in Quebec City. They built it, but nobody came! Maybe it should be dismantled and sent piece by piece to Seattle!
Quebec: You don't deserve this recreational facility based on your track record!
Mr.Sauga
ReplyDeleteWhy are you such an angry man when it comes to Quebec? You left 35 years ago and you comment more than anyone here and its always this hateful vitriol spewing out of your mouth. You obviously dislike 90 percent or more of francophones..we get it Mr Sauga..but get over it..you are not the only person in the world who suffered some injustice. You are what..in your 60s or 70s now..and still nonstop..quebec bashing..quebec sucks.and on and on..its pointless.
Like Ontario is such a bastion of excellence..a debt which is now higher than quebecs..a city that everyone in canada hates which is soulless and frankly boring..real estate that is ridiculously over priced. You guys are all dumb enough to elect a former crack heroine dealer who is making a run for making Trump look like a genius. I think Quebec and Montreal are actually looking pretty good to me..thank you very much.
I personally am not a big fan of this royalmount project..and I am an anglophone..and other anglophones dont like it. Have you been to west edmonton mall..its a big ugly complex that did suck the life out of downtown edmonton. Ste Catherine street is pretty well the only street left in canada that has any life on it..even Yonge street pales..and forget about any other canadian city.
Even if the number of cars estimated is exaggerated do we really need any more traffic in one of the most congested parts of Montreal..it doesn't make any sense to me..and 1.5 billion dollars for this behemoth. Canada is full of shopping centres..do we really need another one especially in Montreal which is one of the few places left in North America that has some culture and soul to it..that has interesting neighborhoods and stores and so on. This project belongs in a place like edmonton or calgary..two cities I know well that have nothing interesting to look at.
totally agree mate. both sauga and royalmount are bad projects.
DeletePart 1 of 2:
DeleteComp, you've got me all wrong. Where do you get this "dislike 90 percent...of francophones" stuff? I don't know anywhere near 0.001% of them. It's just that anyone involved in commercial improvements in Quebec (mostly politicians) seem to hate it when any piddly little thing that is a good idea isn't their idea, and well over 90% of all politicians and public servants (with about 80% of the population) are Old Stock Québécois. They'll spit if project names aren't 100% French. They'll get hostile if the creativeness is not 100% French.
To give you an example of the Quebec public service, I personally know a fellow who immigrated from Cuba as he married a woman in the demographics of minority. Her family origins are a Cuban mother and a Jewish father. He was in Cuba building a successful business when he met this woman's mother. He already had successful ventures in Montreal.
Anyway, prior to emigrating to Quebec, he learned both English and French (2nd and 3rd languages) and continued taking French lessons once he came to Quebec. He's a professional engineer, took the P.Eng program to acquire his designation, and got a job as an elevator inspector with the Quebec Government. Imagine...he beat out the local talent! Better yet, he is the only one of the whole personnel who speaks English. West Island assignments? All his!
Think of it...THINK OF IT! Here comes a guy from another country, learns Canada's two official languages before he deplanes in officially unilingual Quebec, and HE is the only elevator inspector in all Quebec who can speak English.
Part 2 of 2:
DeleteCrash test dummies, your Quebec. He had y'all beat by the time he set foot on the tarmac! Oh...and I forgot to mention he's actually not simply trilingual, but quadrilingual...Spanish, English, French and Joual. In Cuba, the professors speak proper French from Europe. He really needed those free French...I mean Joual lessons upon arriving in Quebec. It was almost as if he had to learn a new language what with the lousy grammar and lexicon spoken in Quebec. Even the Quebec Government constantly bitches about the poor grammatical quality of French in Quebec. I'd get e-mails and chats with NO accents in the writing. I put them there because in the later grades we were practically crucified if we forgot so much as an accent in our French classes. Lose a whole mark for a spelling error to a response on a test. Try and use words like booker (pronounced bouquet) and upgrader to our French teachers. That would be good for ridicule and being raked over the coals by the French teacher! My grammar and punctuation in written correspondence was better than theirs and I'm not fluent.
Now, if you or anyone else doesn't like the Royalmount project, that is unconditionally your prerogative, but that's not the interpretation I got from Mr. Berlach, the author of this blog.
Like President Trump says of the media, fake news. Don't get me wrong, I'm no supporter of that idiot. As far as I'm concerned, he's the leader of the Parti Américain, the U.S. nationalist version of the dying Parti Québécois. His base is made up of the most racist bumpkins and ignoramuses in America. The Journal de Montréal is the purveyor of fake news with their pride and joy being an extensive sports section and pictures of scantily clad women. The Toronto Sun was the equivalent, but even that rag of a paper has toned it down to something marginally acceptable.
Finally, the debt level in Ontario: Comp, you're right! 100%. The Dike, Kathleen Wynn was a completely reckless spendthrift, hence her party was slashed from the majority to a measly seven seats...at least five too many as far as I'm concerned. It's only too bad the voters here four years earlier didn't have enough of her impudent means of governing.
Interestingly, François Leggo (see, didn't forget the cedilla under the c) just yesterday expressed his disappointment Ontario won't be building a French language university, but the Dike was ready to do that while giving $14,000 rebates for affluent buyers of expensive "green" cars. I'm sure your precious Journal de M clearly ridiculed that change of direction by Doug Ford, but as Mr. Ford explained, there are over 300 French programs in current Ontario universities that are underutilized, so now austerity measures are going to have to be made for his predecessor's spendthrift ways. Think the J de M will report Ford's rebuttal? Didn't Couillard do the same thing? Isn't Mr. Legault known for being fiscally conservative? Wait'll your first budget!
"Interestingly, François Leggo (see, didn't forget the cedilla under the c) just yesterday expressed his disappointment Ontario won't be building a French language university,"
DeleteThis was all over the news yesterday. Is there even a practical necessity for such a university?
I read and heard allegations that francophobia drove Ford's decision, and not practical considerations. When defining "-phobias", how did we go from pressing these charges based on actions taken (i.e. if Ford went ahead and gutted funding to an existing AND popular AND profitable Toronto-based French language university) vs now pressing charges based on actions not taken (as in Ford refusing to take up an impractical undertaking)? Just like it used to take some negative actions towards homosexuals to be labeled a homophobe, but today some LGBT group will label you a homophobe if you refuse to attend a gay parade (e.g. Stephen Harper in the past, and even Francois Legault some months ago)...
It's odd how things are getting redefined and how just your passivity may land you in trouble. These days just by staying out of things and minding your own business can get you labelled as some sort of "-phobe" just because you fail to back some "social justice" cause...Hence Ford must be a francophobe too.
Right you are, adski! Of course the French Quebec media is going to crap all over Ford. He's not eliminating French advocacy in Ontario, he's just amalgamating it under the Ombudsman's office. The Ontario Ombudsman is a Francophone, and I've seen job postings in the Ombudsman's office...most of those postings ask for bilinguals.
DeleteWhere did you read and hear the allegations? Why the French fake news media, of course. No, I'm not trying to advocate The Donald, but in many cases he isn't far off. I know people who personally were misquoted on stories about them, deliberately edited and/or dubbed. Quebec is infamous for it, esp. going against minorities, and mostly against Anglophones at that. After all, Anglophones are the "enemy of the [Quebec] people, at least to the demographic majority.
Oh, and complicated, to fortify an answer to a previous question, it does still anger me that Canada is only as good as its last dollar sent to Quebec whether for being compensated for services otherwise administered by the feds (like collecting GST, and for handling its own immigration) and most of all, that giant, juicy teat a.k.a. equalization payments. When a former 100,000% separatist minister of educations states «l'anglais est une langue étrangère», yeah, I have a serious problem with that...DEAD serious! That's so because while she was the only one to state it, I'm sure there were millions applauding her for saying it...much like that dead parasite that berated, BY HIS OWN ADMISSION several weeks after Referendum Night 1995, the Jews, Greeks and Italians, i.e. "Money and the ethnic vote". If he was in the cups when he said it, so much the better. His subconscious came to the fore that night, but he boasted about it about six weeks later or so on a political junket in Calgary. Mel Gibson, a rabid anti-Semite like his father before him, also went on a vitriolic anti-Semitic tirade years ago when he was stopped for drunk driving. His subconscious came to the fore.
I won't pull punches here, readers. When Leggo the Eggo stated to Ford he was "disappointed" (way more than that, to be sure) with the scrapping of the proposal to open a French language college or uni, he did state there are over 300 French language programs already in existing post-secondary institutions, and to reduce the cost of separate bureaucracies, he's rolling French language advocacy under the already bilingually served Office of the Ombudsman, as per above.
May I also remind readers that as far back as late last century, there were already about 50% more French schools in Ontario as English schools in Quebec. Not because of demographics, but because separatist Quebec deliberately placed the English speaking community and its schools within the crosshairs.
Tell you what, comp: I'll shut up forever when Quebec (fat chance) takes back no more federal money that what it puts into the federal coffers, or nothing upon separation. Think that will happen in the lifetimes of your grandchildren's great grandchildren? Not even if pigs could fly.
Agree or disagree, complicated and student, that's where I stand, and you can curse and berate me until you draw your last breaths. Unless my conditions in the above paragraph are met, I've made my stand until I draw MY last breath.
Mr.Sauga
ReplyDeleteYou always have a story to back you up..but stories are often not facts..they are anecdotes. I have lots of stories also about dealings with Jewish people which I could also make all sorts of assumptions in general on the Jewish community but I dont think that would be fair and we could say the same for any community. Its just that you are constantly spewing venom against Quebec and notably francophones in Quebec. Its getting really really old..and frankly you are getting old too..dont spend the rest of your life raging against demons from the past..get over it.
Hé comp: You have your ideas, I have mine, and THAT is the last word on the subject!
ReplyDeleteIf you don't twist your ankles in any potholes as you cross the street, this is a great idea. But I don't think the roads paved with water-thinned tar are going to be up for repairs any time soon.
ReplyDelete