If there is one thing certain that can be said of the Quebec electorate, it is that there is nothing to be taken as certain.
Quebec voters, unlike Canadians outside the province, have always been volatile with little brand loyalty.
Take for example the great Bloc Quebecois wave of 2000 and 2004 where they elected 54 MPs from Quebec with 49% of the popular vote as well as the Orange crush of of 2011 where the NDP wave took 59 of the 75 Quebec seats with an 43% of the popular vote.
Commentators and pundit who predict the demise of Maxime Bernier and his descent into obscurity are either dead wrong or whistling through the graveyard.
Maxime Bernier arrives on the political scene in Quebec at the most opportune moment, with voters itching for a new face and a new ideology.
With the Bloc in its death throes and the shine off the Trudeau apple, voters are desperate for a choice, one that Bernier fits to a tee. That support will transcend English/French lines as well as federalist/separatist ideology.
First let us look at the sovereigntists and soft nationalists, who understand that the Bloc is a spent force, and who now see Bernier as the only legitimate defender of Quebec culture, a stalwart against forced multiculturalism of the federal Liberals.
To hard and soft nationalists alike, the notion that if they are to be stuck in Canada, a party that defends traditional Quebec culture in Quebec as well as traditional Canadian culture in the ROC is a compromise made in Heaven.
Those remaining Bloc MPS already understand that an independent Quebec is no longer an option and so most, if not all, would jump to support a Bernier party.
Bernier would be careful to demand that BQ MPs publicly disavow sovereignty before allowing them into the party and I'm sure those who wish to preserve their cushy jobs in Ottawa would make the pragmatic decision to do so.
There are many Canadians who support Bernier's view on preserving Canadian culture and the danger of a European type of illegal immigrant invasion. This percentage is even a higher in Quebec.
Justin Trudeau's branding those who wish to preserve the Canadian identity as it is as intolerant, is already alienating Quebec voters who refuse to be insulted because they fear that their Quebecois culture being eroded by uncheck illegal immigration.
It is a much bigger issue than anyone in the federal Liberals understand because it touches two raw nerves, protecting traditional Quebec identity and law and order.
Quebecers have always been a people of law and order and throughout the tumultuous years of the independence movement, have never shown an inkling of support for lawlessness or upheaval.
The idea that foreigners can traipse over the border with impunity, while regular Canadians must put up with interminable line-up at the border crossing in order return home from vacation is utterly unacceptable.
Bernier's deep conservatism, his opposition supply management and call for an end to government subsidies may in theory hurt him in Quebec, but it won't.
While the organized unions and dairy farmers will cackle, ordinary Quebecers will ignore their entreaties, with the issue of defending Quebec's French identity in Canada as the over-riding issue of the election.
Let us remember that the Bloc Quebecois wave and the subsequent NDP wave were both predicated on the defence of traditional Quebec culture and language.
The last election saw Quebecers caught up in Trudeaumania like the rest of the country. While Trudeau's support is slipping, but holding in Canada, Quebec is a different story where Trudeau is fast gaining a reputation as selling out Quebec to immigrants.
As for the NDP, its already weakening support in Quebec is further collapsing because of their new leader, Jagmeet Singh, a character who represents what the majority of Quebecers loathe, foreign religious orthodoxy.
Bernier is an extremely popular figure who will get re-elected in his home riding no matter what the party affiliation. His status as a favourite son and staunch defender of traditional Quebec and Canadian culture is the one and only issue that matters federally.
And so it seems that the stars are aligned for Bernier who perhaps realizes what the pundits are incapable of understanding.
When I say Bernier can win 30-40 seats in Quebec, I am being conservative, with the Liberal fortress Montreal and Laval, just about the only safe ridings for the Liberals.
As for a Bernier political party in the rest of Canada, the decision to run candidates will be difficult and I shall leave that discussion for another blog post, but there is a scenario whereby Bernier can actually insure a Scheer Conservative government through coalition.
As for the pundits predicting the premature political death of Bernier, consider their track record where none were able to foretell seismic shifts in Quebec voter intentions.
Excellent analyis. Max will get a significant number of seats, and while that may split the "conservative" vote, not much loss as under Scheer just how "conservative" would his gov't be? The media will make every effort to marginilize him to keep us from hearing about issues that actually matter such immigration, energy, government subsidies etc. Hard to see how he gets traction outside of Quebec without appearing in a debate. The English media do it's assigned job by marginalizing him as the "far-right" Quebec candidate - plus add the tinge of "racism" while their at it. With all that he's up against, it's hard to imagine him getting his message through the media filters. Add in the lack of conservative enthusiam for Scheer and looks like we're doomed with four more years of Mr. Dressup! The good news is that Max will make a fool of liberal policies in a take no prisoners style, something we have never really had in Canada.
ReplyDeleteI would loved to see Maxime get 30 or 40 seats but think you are way too optimistic. He would likely get 5 seats all inQuebec. New parties dont just grab a bunch of seats that quickly unless there is a really rallying cause such as independance which galvanized the Bloc Quebecois. Look how many decades the NDP has toiled without getting that many seats or the Green party which has done even worse.
ReplyDeleteI think many will think he is just a sore loser and many will not forget his infamous Couillard affair in which he left top secret documents at his girlfriends apartment..amateurish. I do agree with many of his views but very wishful thinking that he will gain much traction within only a year. Canadians always play it pretty safe oscillating back and forth between the Libs and the Cons..still think this is a gift for Trudeau,.
Piggyback on Scheer now, jump ship after the election, then take the time to build the team.
DeleteBy the way on another note in our provincial election. Anyone notice who is running in Jacque Cartier for the Liberals..none other than the 32 year old son of the former Liberal in this riding?? Nepotism at its worse..so now we know the real reason Geoffrey Kelley retired..to pave the way for sonny boy to walk into the safest riding in Quebec if not Canada.
ReplyDeleteI am so sick and tired of seeing children of well known politicians waltzing into politics on the coat tails of their parents..often woefully less experienced than their parents were..ie Justin Trudeau who is slowly wrecking this country but is great at selfies and other superficial tasks..how about George W Bush..or the attempt of catherine mulroney.
What the hell do most 32 year olds know about anything?? This Greg Kelley now gets a cush job for life thanks to his dad..I wish voters would punish these token politicians but it seems name recognition trumps everything now.
It's no surprise Geoff Kelley has stepped aside. In fact, I'm surprised he didn't do so at least 8-9 years ago because he could collect his maximum pension at that time--75% of his last salary + indexing for inflation. By now he'd be earning his salary sitting on his ass or doing something else and therefore double dipping.
DeleteComp, if you're not happy and live in his riding, don't vote for him. If the majority in Jacques Cartier feel that way, they can vote for someone else. Just another kapo in a predominantly English speaking riding. It's only a cushy job if people keep voting for him. Why don't you run as an independent in that riding and challenge him. Push English speakers' rights like the Equality Party did!
Its impossible for the Liberals to lose in this riding..they win with 85-90 percent of the vote every election. I definitely will not be voting for him..and have not voted for the Libs one time..my point is how shady the Liberals are by parachuting Kelley jr into his dads riding as if there was NO OTHER person who was better qualified. Kelley junior has even less credentials than Trudeau..this is only possible because anglos in west Montreal are total sheep. Its impossible to change their minds..I am sure they would vote for a pedophile, a monkey, a dead person under the Liberal banner.
DeleteI bet many of them wont even realize they arent voting for the older Kelley as they have the same name. Its just another example of the incredible Liberal arrogance for anglo voters..they do next to nothing for us other than not holding a referendum..they are flagrantly corrupt..but this really is the icing on the cake..
Running as an independant..I would be lucky to get 1 percent of the vote even if I knocked on every door in the riding..it aint gonna happen..I and others are not into banging our head against a brick wall.
Look at these credentials..
Conseiller politique/ Political advisor
Company NameSecretariat for Relations with English-speaking Quebecers
Dates Employed2017 – Present
Employment Duration1 yr
LocationQuebec, Canada
Cabinet du premier ministre du Québec
Conseiller politique/ Political advisor
Company NameCabinet du premier ministre du Québec
Dates EmployedJan 2017 – Oct 2017
Employment Duration10 mos
Ministère du Conseil exécutif - Gouvernement du Québec
Policy advisor to the Minister of intergovernmental relations in Quebec
Company NameMinistère du Conseil exécutif - Gouvernement du Québec
Dates EmployedApr 2014 – Jan 2017
Employment Duration2 yrs 10 mos
LocationQuebec City
Groupe GVM
Consultant
Company NameGroupe GVM
Dates EmployedJan 2013 – Apr 2014
Employment Duration1 yr 4 mos
Liberal Party of Quebec
Policy Analyst
Company NameLiberal Party of Quebec
Dates EmployedOct 2010 – Sep 2012
Employment Duration2 yrs
Education
Queen's University
Queen's University
Degree NameMasters Field Of StudyPublic Administration
Dates attended or expected graduation 2009 – 2010
McGill University
McGill University
Degree NameBA Field Of StudyHistory & Political Science
Dates attended or expected graduation 2006 – 2009
Université du Québec à Montréal
Université du Québec à Montréal
Degree NameBachelor of Laws (LLB)
Dates attended or expected graduation 2013
(Not completed)
POlitical advisor..total bs positions..this guy has never had a real job..he wasnt capable of completing more than a year of his law degree..but he WILL be our representative because of some backroom deal with his dad..and his dad by the way did nothing useful either..
Regarding Kelley the younger, I was surprised the liberals didn't use the safest QC riding to parachute in a star francophone candidate. Surely his appointment was a condition for Geoffrey Kelly to step down. I suppose the Liberals also feel a need for a few quislings to keep the anglo community on board and mollified, in the tent etc. Great "work" if you can get it. Now he gets to go to Quebec city and can vote to denounce the use of "bonjour/hi" etc. . If he hangs in long enough, keeps his nose clean and doesn't rock any boats he'll get a minor cabinet position where he can spearhead new appeasement policies for our "autochtones". Set for life at 32! I'd rather vote for 18 year old the Conservatives are running! Plus ca change etc...
ReplyDeleteDonald: As I wrote above. Interestingly, there was a fellow named Perrin Beatty who ran in the Ontario riding of Fergus from age 21 until he was defeated at age 43. Back then, he could start collecting his pension for his 22 years of service (i.e., half his very young life, and many years as a cabinet minister, i.e., more coin at the end of the line) the very day after he was defeated...and did. He got nice, cushy jobs after that...patronage appointments, first with the CBC after taking time off (sitting on his pension-cushioned ass). Then he got other neat appointments.
DeleteSo put up, shut up or put your money where your mouth is and oppose the guy!
Bernier win 30-40 seats? Naaahhh...I don't see it. He showed a dire lack of professionalism leaving the Conservatives the way he did, and while I don't think Andrew "Dolly Dimples" Sheer will win the election...unfortunately...I don't see Bernier putting a big dent in his dimples.
ReplyDeleteThere are those who felt Dimples' win was sneaky, but isn't that what politics is? It's now a Machiavellian world out there given the crazy shenanigans happening in the DSA (i.e., Divided States of America).
If he wants to be a serious threat to either Andrew Scheer or Justin Trudeau, “Mad Max” is going to have to go into the very areas that frighten both of them. This is on top of getting together his team in less than a year.
ReplyDeleteIn the case of the former, that would be Quebec – especially the English, Montreal, and English Montreal – and the Maritimes. Since he can speak the language, Bernier has a fighting chance of resonating with a long-suffering base that has been effectively bullied into a unilateral relationship. They’re openly tired of the same old same old.
In the case of the latter, that would be the industrial belts (metal, grain, et al). The natural resources sector has a nasty habit of being the votes that change governments. They’re not going to have any patience or sympathy for the Muslims that keep swamping our borders. Especially not when their taxes are going into the services these parasites are getting (including Mounties for bellhops).
The dairy cartel was not the reason he lost out on the party reins on the final leadership ballot. It never occurred to him that he wasn’t the only one who wanted to win. He hasn’t stayed quiet about his loss since. And he also has a horrible temper he really needs to work on — in stark contrast to Scheer’s cool head.
And there’s two final factors to consider: one is the Orange Wave of 2011 hinged on Jack Layton. Would that Layton had not died shortly afterward, the wave would continue today. The other is Elizabeth May, who thought along much the lines that he does. She’s never moved out of the fringe party ranks.
Lots of luck, Max. You're going to need it.
The bottom line is that Canadians are centrist to leftist so it will be next to impossible for a right wing party to hold power. The only way it could happen is a major economnc downturn..if the propertty bubble really collapses..we go into a deep long lasting recession..Trump slaps 25 percent tariffs on autos and decimates our auto industry and so on..then people might look at the other parties. MÙy worry is that these things will happen at some point but by then the Liberals will have done so much damage to this country that it will be hard for anyone to dig us out.
Delete